Hidden Gems: Unexplored Neighborhoods Off the Beaten Path in Costa Rica

When most people think of buying property in Costa Rica, they picture hotspots like Tamarindo, Jacó, or Nosara. And while those areas have a lot going for them—great communities, amenities, and proven rental markets—they’re not the only options worth exploring.

In fact, some of Costa Rica’s best opportunities for buyers and investors in 2025 and beyond lie in places you won’t find splashed across travel blogs or Instagram. These are hidden gems: small neighborhoods, up-and-coming towns, and off-the-beaten-path communities where you can enjoy authentic Pura Vida living, strong growth potential, and often better value for your money.

Let’s take a tour of some of these overlooked spots.

Why Look Beyond the Usual Costa Rica Hotspots?

• Better value: Popular towns are great—but they’re also priced accordingly. Exploring just 20–30 minutes beyond the main hubs can stretch your budget further.

• Authentic living: Smaller communities often have a more “Tico feel,” perfect if you want immersion in local culture instead of a tourist-heavy scene.

• Long-term upside: As infrastructure, airports, and digital connectivity improve, many of today’s “hidden gems” could become tomorrow’s hotspots.

Hidden Gem #1: Playa Bejuco (Central Pacific)

Just 30 minutes south of Jacó, Playa Bejuco is a stunning stretch of sand with a quieter, laid-back feel. Unlike its busier neighbor, Bejuco offers space, tranquility, and investment upside.

• Why it’s special: Wide beaches, consistent surf, and a growing expat presence—but without the crowds.

• Real estate vibe: Gated communities, new-build homes, and parcels of land at more approachable prices than Jacó.

• Best for: Buyers who want rental potential close to tourist activity but prefer a quieter home base.

Hidden Gem #2: Ojochal (Southern Zone)

The Southern Zone gets more love every year, but Ojochal remains one of its under-the-radar stars.

• Why it’s special: Known as Costa Rica’s “culinary capital,” Ojochal blends French, Italian, and Costa Rican influences with stunning mountain-ocean views.

• Real estate vibe: Hillside villas with infinity pools, mid-range homes tucked in the jungle, and strong opportunities for vacation rentals.

• Best for: Foodies, retirees, and anyone who wants a close-knit international community with a focus on lifestyle.

Hidden Gem #3: Playa Potrero (North Pacific, near Flamingo)

Everyone’s heard of Flamingo for its new marina, but just next door sits Playa Potrero, a relaxed fishing village with a big future.

• Why it’s special: Calm waters, a walkable beachfront community, and proximity to the high-end development of Flamingo without the same price tag.

• Real estate vibe: A mix of affordable condos, beachside homes, and land that’s still more reasonably priced.

• Best for: Investors looking for long-term appreciation tied to Flamingo’s marina growth.

Hidden Gem #4: Atenas (Central Valley)

If you’ve dreamed of a cooler climate without sacrificing accessibility, Atenas is worth a look.

• Why it’s special: Famous for having “the best climate in the world” (warm days, cool nights), Atenas also offers easy access to San José and the international airport.

• Real estate vibe: Spacious homes with valley views, coffee-farm parcels, and gated communities popular with retirees.

• Best for: Full-time residents who want year-round comfort, healthcare access, and proximity to the city—without actually living in it.

Hidden Gem #5: Playa San Miguel (Nicoya Peninsula)

On the Nicoya Peninsula, beyond the surf hubs of Nosara and Santa Teresa, you’ll find Playa San Miguel, a serene, wide-open beach that feels like Costa Rica 20 years ago.

• Why it’s special: Miles of pristine sand, very few tourists, and a completely tranquil atmosphere.

• Real estate vibe: Larger plots of land and eco-friendly developments designed for privacy and sustainability.

• Best for: Buyers who want to go truly “off-grid” while still holding a long-term investment in a region with strong eco-tourism potential.

Hidden Gem #6: Grecia (Central Valley Highlands)

If coffee farms and mountain views sound like your pura vida dream, Grecia deserves a visit.

• Why it’s special: A traditional Costa Rican town with a slower pace, authentic markets, and a growing expat community.

• Real estate vibe: Homes with mountain and volcano views at a fraction of coastal prices.

• Best for: Retirees or long-term residents who want cooler weather, affordability, and cultural immersion.

Tips for Exploring Hidden Gem Neighborhoods

• Visit in more than one season: A quiet neighborhood in the dry season can feel very different once the rains arrive.

• Check infrastructure: Internet, road access, and utilities can vary more in less-developed areas.

• Think lifestyle first: Do you want walkability? Restaurants? Or total seclusion? Hidden gems come in many flavors.

• Work with a local expert: An agent who knows the backroads and up-and-coming areas can save you years of guesswork.

Final Thoughts: The Real Treasure is Balance

Costa Rica’s best-known real estate markets are popular for a reason—they offer proven rental demand and established expat networks. But if you’re looking for better value, quieter living, and the chance to get ahead of the curve, exploring hidden gem neighborhoods is a smart move.

Whether it’s beachside calm in Bejuco, culinary culture in Ojochal, or highland breezes in Atenas, the country has options for every lifestyle and budget—you just need to know where to look.

Ready to Discover Your Hidden Gem?

At Pura Vida Real Estate Tours, we don’t just show you the tourist towns. We take you deeper—to the neighborhoods most buyers never get to see. Whether you’re hunting for your dream home or your next investment, our tours will match your lifestyle to the right location so you can buy with confidence.